Christmas Card Printing Guide: Best Services, Paper Types & Costs

You need cards that feel substantial, ship on time, and don’t cost a fortune. Here’s a people-first guide to pick a printer, paper, and timeline—plus how to get a flawless, print-ready file in under a minute if you’re short on time.

Quick take (order tonight)

• Best value: Costco (if you’re a member) or Vistaprint with a sale.
• Luxury feel: Minted or Shutterfly premium—only with a 40–50% code.
• Last-minute pickup: Walmart/Costco in-store; expect basic quality.
• Paper: 130–150 lb matte or satin. Skip thin glossy.
• Order by: Nov 20 for calm; latest Dec 7 with expedited.
• No reshoot needed: Upload your best photo and generate 18 print-ready, 3000x4000px scenes in 60 seconds → ThatMoment.Studio.

Who to use (real picks, not theory)

• Costco: ~$25 for 25 cards, in-store pickup, solid quality. Membership required.
• Vistaprint: ~$20–35 with sales; “good enough” quality; constant promos.
• Shutterfly: Strong quality; only buy on deep sale; free addressing on some tiers.
• Minted: Best papers/designs; pricey unless you catch a sale.
• Walmart: Fastest/same-day; basic quality for emergencies.

Paper and finish that matter

• Weight: Go 130–150 lb. 100 lb feels flimsy; 180+ lb is luxury.
• Finish:
  • Matte: no glare, easy to write on, premium feel.
  • Satin/pearl: a soft sheen; best middle ground.
  • Glossy: more pop but fingerprints and glare; feels less premium.
• Invest in paper weight before gimmicks (scalloped edges, shapes).

Price reality check (5x7, pre-promo)

• Budget: $0.60–$0.90 (Walmart, Costco).
• Mid: $1.00–$1.80 (Vistaprint, Shutterfly on sale).
• Premium: $2.50–$4.00 (Minted, Shutterfly premium off-sale).
• Luxury: $4.00+ (foil, letterpress boutique).

Quantity cuts cost: 50 is ~10–15% cheaper per card than 25; 100 can be 20–30% cheaper.

Timeline that won’t burn you

• Ideal: Order by Nov 20.
• Safe: Order by Nov 30 with standard shipping.
• Risky: Dec 1–7 with rush production + expedited shipping ($30–$60 extra).
• Last resort: Same/next-day pickup (Walmart/Costco) with basic quality.
  December backlogs are real; “3-day” often slips—build buffer.

Print-ready file checklist

• Export at 300 DPI in sRGB, final size 5x7 (or your chosen format).
• Keep faces/text 0.25" inside edges (safe zone); add 0.125" bleed if required.
• Use high-res: minimum 1500x2100 px for 5x7; 3000x4000 px looks crisp.
• Avoid neon colors; they print muddy.
• Order one sample if time allows before a 75-card run.

If your background is messy or light is bad, don’t reshoot—upload the best-expression frame and let AI rebuild the scene (Tree Farm, Modern Minimal, Romantic Winter, Santa’s Workshop), then export at 5x7.

Saving money without trashing quality

1. Never pay full price: Sales are constant. Wait 3–7 days or use Black Friday/Cyber Monday codes (often 40–60% off).
2. Compare totals, not base price: Shipping can erase “low” card prices. In-store pickup saves $6–$12.
3. Order once: Count your list + 10–15% buffer. Reorders cost more with extra shipping.
4. Use pickup when possible: Faster and cheaper (Costco/Walmart).

What truly affects quality

• Source photo resolution and color: 3000x4000 px, well-lit.
• Paper weight: 130–150 lb minimum.
• Printer choice: Minted/Shutterfly (best), Costco/Vistaprint (great value), Walmart (basic).

Matte vs glossy matters less than the above; corners/envelope linings are aesthetic, not quality.

If you have no time to shoot again

• Take one clean portrait by a window, plain wall.
• Upload, choose a preset, and download 18 variations at print resolution.
• Send to your printer of choice; pick in-store pickup if the calendar is tight.

Create Print-Ready Christmas Photos in 60 Seconds →

---

More Christmas Card Resources:

• Christmas Card Messages
• AI Christmas Photos Ultimate Guide
• Christmas Photo Mistakes to Avoid